Backyard SmokeMaster BBQ Podcast — Episode 85

Prefer to listen? Catch the full episode above, or read the recap below.

Let me say it plainly: you can’t really call yourself a backyard pit master if you’re only running one pit. That might sound crazy to folks who don’t share this affliction — Society brother Jeff put it best in the chat: “What you mean you can have more than one grill? Crazy.” — but for those of us serious about leveling up, having more than one cooker isn’t a flex. It’s essential.

A little personal context on why this topic is front of mind for me: I recently bought two new smokers — a Smokeslinger direct-heat cooker and a Liberty 94 offset (both from the same company, and no, this isn’t sponsored — that was my own hard-earned money). I picked them up because I’ve become a licensed MEHKO here in California — a Micro Enterprise Home Kitchen Operation — which means I’m now cleared to sell barbecue out of my own home kitchen after passing the county’s inspection. Going pro meant I needed more capacity and more cooking styles. (If you’re in the East Bay and want to taste my barbecue, sign up for menu and pre-order alerts at backyardsmokemaster.com/clayton.)

So here are seven strong reasons you need more than one good pit in your backyard.

1. Different Tools for Different Cooks

You wouldn’t sear a ribeye on an offset — offsets are built for low and slow. Think of your cookers like the knives in your kitchen: a chef’s knife, a boning knife, a paring knife. Each one has a distinct role.

A wood-fired pizza oven lives at 700–900°F; an offset smoker cruises at 225–275°F. You’re not cooking ribs in the pizza oven, and you’re not getting a crisp crust off the offset. A pellet grill gives you set-it-and-forget-it convenience and a subtle smoke; a Santa Maria grill, with grates you raise and lower over an open fire, gives you the ultimate in manual control. All great tools — for completely different jobs.

2. Cooking Capacity and Crowd Size

The number of people you’re feeding should drive the cooker you reach for. A large offset gives you room for multiple briskets or six or seven racks of ribs — perfect for a big gathering. A direct-heat grill handles the quick weeknight family dinner.

And don’t sleep on the big ceramic cookers. A large Kamado Joe or Big Green Egg gives you the ultimate versatility — low and slow or hot and fast — with the capacity to run multiple pork butts or chickens at once instead of shuttling food on and off a smaller grill. Want to dream big? A Weber Ranch Kettle is the classic kettle scaled way up: dozens of burgers, multiple racks of ribs, and yes — even a whole hog.

3. Flexibility With Your Time

We’ve all been there: sometimes you’ve got twelve hours, sometimes you’ve got thirty minutes. A direct-heat pit is your friend on a weeknight for fast sears, chicken, and steaks. An offset is perfect for a weekend when you can tend a long fire and enjoy the process.

Own both and you’re never boxed in by the clock. Add a pellet grill as your “third gear” — set-it-and-forget-it smoke for overnight cooks and busy days when you can’t babysit a fire — and you’d be hard pressed to find a scenario you’re not ready for.

4. Fuel and Fire Management

Different fuels are different skill sets, and each one earns its keep:

• Direct-heat cookers burn hot coals for fast cooks with less fuel waste on smaller meals.
• Pellet grills use compressed pellets and an auger — hands-off and easy, though less smoke than a stick burner.
• Gas grills run on propane or natural gas for instant heat and control. I’ve been hard on gas in the past, but I’ll give it its due — Meathead himself loves a gas grill. The catch is no real smoke flavor unless you supplement with a chip tray or smoke tube.
• Electric smokers are super convenient (great for apartments or strict HOAs) but won’t match the depth of a wood or charcoal fire.

Owning multiple fuel systems lets you balance effort, flavor, and convenience based on what you’re cooking and how much time you have.

5. Different Flavor Profiles

Every cooker brings its own flavor to the table:

• Direct heat: crispy edges, steakhouse char, great caramelization.
• Offset: deep smoke rings, super tender meat, true low-and-slow authenticity.
• Pellet: consistent mild smoke and convenience — and a great excuse to experiment by mixing pellet flavors (cherry and apple, apple and hickory). (Tip from the chat: Royal Oak’s charcoal pellets are even better blended with a fruit pellet.)
• Gas: clean heat and subtle flavor; punch it up with a smoke tube or wood chips.
• Electric: a lighter, cleaner profile — and the go-to for cold smoking cheese or fish at under 100°F.

More cookers means a broader flavor palette and a lot more room to play.

6. Redundancy and Reliability

This is the one people underrate until it saves them. When you’ve got a backup, you’re never stuck:

• Long brisket cook and a storm rolls in? Move the meat from your offset to a pellet grill or electric smoker.
• Running hot and fast and you run out of charcoal? Pivot to the gas grill and finish those steaks without missing a beat.
• Pellet grill auger jams or you get a flame-out mid-cook (it happens — I’ve been there)? Transfer the food to charcoal or gas and save the cook.

Anything that relies on electricity or moving parts deserves a backup — and that’s exactly why I love a charcoal cooker like a kettle, drum, or Weber Smokey Mountain: it’s just you, the charcoal, and the fire, nothing to fail. A gas grill is a reliable instant-heat backup too (just keep a spare propane tank on hand). And an oversized pit like a Kamado Joe or Ranch Kettle means you’ve always got a big-crowd cooker ready if a smaller grill is out of commission.

7. You Grow as a Pit Master

Here’s maybe the best reason of all — and the one to mention to your significant other when you’re making your case. Every cooker has a lesson to teach:

• Offsets teach fire management, airflow, and how to control a live wood fire — plus patience and precision. To me, that’s the ultimate pit master education.
• Direct-heat cookers teach heat control over coals, managing flare-ups, and the art of hot and fast.
• Pellet grills teach consistency and recipe development — use that steady temp to experiment with rubs, injections, and flavor profiles.
• Gas grills teach efficiency and adaptability for quick cooks and testing techniques.
• Electric smokers teach you cold smoking.
• Large charcoal cookers teach pure versatility — low and slow, roasting, and searing at extreme heat, all in one pit.

Those skills transfer across every cooker you own. So owning more than one isn’t just about cooking more food — it’s about sharpening your skills, mastering different fuels, and building the confidence to handle just about any barbecue challenge that comes your way.

The community had some great two-cooker combos in the chat — a Weber Smokey Mountain paired with a Slow ‘N Sear kettle, a Smokeslinger with a Santa Maria, even old-school cinder-block builds. So let me ask you: if you could only run two outdoor cookers, what would they be? That’s exactly the kind of thing we talk about all week long inside the community.

Join the Backyard SmokeMaster Society — it’s free, and it takes less than a minute. You don’t have to go on this barbecue journey alone. Head to backyardsmokemaster.com/society and jump in.

Note: The links above are affiliate links where I may receive a small commission. You will not pay more for using these links.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download