Backyard SmokeMaster BBQ Podcast — Episode 81

Prefer to listen? Catch the full episode above, or read the recap below.

There’s no shortage of barbecue gadgets out there. Every time you pick up your phone, the algorithm has another shiny toy waiting for you — some new tool that promises to turn you into a pitmaster overnight. But here’s the thing, barbecue family: not everything lives up to the hype.

So in Episode 81, I pulled back the curtain on the tools I think are the most overhyped in the barbecue world — and yes, full confession, I’ve personally bought just about every one of them. Lesson learned so you don’t have to. Then we got into the underrated gear that actually earns its place at your cook.

The golden rule before we dive in? If it looks and sounds too good to be true, it probably is. There are no shortcuts to great barbecue. It comes down to patience and planning. It’s about the cook, not the gadgets.

The Overhyped: Tools That Talk a Big Game

Electric charcoal fire starters

These work, and there’s a place for them in certain situations. But for everyday cooks? I’ll take a chimney starter every time. When I tested an electric starter, it didn’t get the job done any faster — it actually took longer. All it really did was blow a lot of hot air around. Fill a chimney with charcoal, light a fire starter underneath, give it 15–20 minutes to ash over, and you’re rolling. Faster, more efficient, and a whole lot cheaper.

Meat claws

I bought these when I first got into pork butts, and common sense should’ve told me I didn’t need them. Your pork butt is already going to be fall-apart tender by the time it’s done. All you really need is a good pair of heavy-duty gloves to protect your hands from the heat, and then go in and shred it by hand. Honestly, it’s more satisfying that way. Skip the claws.

Rib racks

In the store they look like a brilliant way to fit three or four racks on your smoker at once. In practice? I’ve used mine maybe once. Unless you’re truly maxed out on space and in a pinch, just lay your ribs flat on the grates — or hang them if you’ve got a drum. There’s another issue too: rib racks bunch the ribs up close together, and we all know you don’t want to overcrowd your smoker. Give your proteins a little breathing room so the smoke can actually get to them.

Pellet tube smokers (a.k.a. smoke tubes)

These had a real moment a few years back, mostly pitched as a way to add smoke flavor to a gas grill, or to boost a pellet smoker that folks felt was running a little light on smoke. Do they work? Sure, they’ll add some smoke. But if you’re truly chasing smoke flavor, a gas grill just isn’t it — and a smoke tube is a few extra fiddly steps (loading it, lighting it) that, in my experience, you stop reaching for pretty quickly.

If you want to push more flavor out of a pellet grill, I’d point you to better fuel before I’d point you to a tube. I’m a fan of Smokin’ Pecan pellets — they’re made from pecan shells and give you a more intense smoke flavor. (Backyard SmokeMaster fam can save 10% with code BACKYARDSMOKEMASTER.) The one spot where a tube genuinely shines is pure cold smoking — but that’s a pretty specific use case.

Wood chip smoke boxes (and wood chips in general)

While we’re here — skip the wood chips altogether. They burn up fast, and the second somebody tells you to soak them, you’ve stopped making smoke and started making steam. If you want real smoke flavor, reach for chunks. Don’t bother with the chip box either.

Bluetooth-only thermometers

This is my controversial pick, so hear me out. Wireless thermometers have come a long way — I love my ThermoWorks RFX, the FireBoard Pulse is a solid number two for me, and Combustion makes a good one too. The technology and the apps are genuinely impressive.

But it’s still technology, and technology can fail. Everything’s great while you’re sitting inside under the A/C watching the temps roll in on your phone — right up until the unit craps out mid-cook and you don’t even know when it dropped off. Picture being 10 hours into a brisket when that happens. That moment of panic is real.

Two more things to know: Bluetooth struggles to punch a signal through the thick quarter-inch steel of a good offset unless you’re standing right next to it, and RF-based units consistently outperform Bluetooth on range. So for any long cook, don’t lean on a Bluetooth-only thermometer as your only set of eyes.

My Biggest BBQ Regrets

Automatic temperature-control fans

This one stings the most. I love the concept — a fan that talks to an app and feeds your fire exactly the right amount of oxygen to hold your target temp. On an efficient charcoal cooker like a kamado or a kettle, fine, it can be a nice-to-have. But I bought a big powerful fan specifically for my offset because I wasn’t confident I could manage the fire myself. Total waste of time and money.

Here’s what I learned: even with the fan, I still had to get up every 40–45 minutes to add a split, and the wood is going to burn the way the wood is going to burn — blowing more air on it didn’t change that. I didn’t actually get good at fire management until I ditched the fan and learned to read the splits. On my offset, a split lasts about 40–45 minutes, the cooker likes to settle around 235–240°F, and when it drifts down toward 220, that’s my cue to add the next split. The minute I stopped obsessing over hitting exactly 225 and let the fire breathe naturally, everything clicked.

A premium grill cover

I waited for the custom-made cover for my offset, paid good money for it, and used it for a little while — then realized wrestling that heavy thing on and off was a chore I was inflicting on myself for no reason. I haven’t touched it in about five years. These days I just season the exterior now and then with a food-grade mineral oil and call it good.

A Safety Note: Throw Out the Wire Brush

When grill brushes came up in the chat, I had to get on my soapbox. Please do not use wire-bristle grill brushes on anything that touches your food. Those tiny bristles break off, you’ll never notice them, and they can end up in your food and seriously hurt someone. I genuinely wish they’d be outlawed. Go with a nylon brush, a steam-style brush, or honestly — pull the grates off and scrub them with soap, water, and a hose. No contamination, no worries.

The Underrated: Tools That Actually Deliver

For all the gadgets I’d tell you to skip, here’s the gear I’d put in your cart today:

• Instant-read thermometer. If you buy one accessory, make it this. You don’t need the expensive one — a solid $20 reader will serve you well. It’s foolproof, it’s accurate, and it gives you a temperature in a split second. Above all, it keeps your food safe. There’s no excuse to be guessing.
• Heat-resistant gloves. Cotton gloves with a nitrile glove pulled over the top let you grab hot meat and move it around without getting burned.
• Charcoal baskets. A good basket makes far more efficient use of your charcoal. Kick Ash Basket makes great ones sized for a lot of popular cookers.
• Grill grates. Fantastic for high-heat searing. Flip them over to the flat side and you’ll get a beautiful, even crust across the whole surface of your meat instead of just sear marks.
• Mesh racks. Underrated workhorses. I lean on mine for pork belly burnt ends — the mesh lets smoke penetrate and makes the food so much easier to move on and off the cooker.
• Aluminum foil pans. Cheap, versatile, and endlessly useful — drip pans, serving vessels, holding cooked meat. I’d even reach for a foil pan over wrapping ribs tightly in foil.

The Real MVP: Your Barbecue Family

Maybe my favorite part of this episode was the chat lighting up with “use what you’ve got” wisdom, and it’s worth passing along:

• Out of rib-rack space? Bamboo skewers or wire coat hangers will stand your ribs up just fine.
• Skip the pricey commercial smoke pot — an old steamer pot with holes and a metal lid does the same job with real wood chunks.
• Reuse foil pans for rib wraps instead of tin foil; folks swear they stay juicier.
• Don’t trash the racks and grates from old grills and toaster ovens — they’re the perfect size for all kinds of jobs.
• Check Harbor Freight for a cheap cover, and a tarp with bungee cords works in a pinch.
• And you don’t need a branded “barbecue journal” — a plain notebook works great. (But do take notes. You should be learning something on every single cook.)

That right there is the whole point. You don’t have to buy every single thing you see on the internet. More often than not, you can replicate what these gadgets promise with stuff you already own — and the money you save is better spent on good meat and good fuel.

So before that next shiny tool lands in your feed, ask yourself: is this a must-have, or is it marketing fluff? Don’t believe the hype. Remember — it’s about the cook, not the gadgets.

Want to keep the conversation going all week long? Join the Backyard SmokeMaster Society — it’s free, so there’s no reason not to. Head to backyardsmokemaster.com/society and jump in. We’re all better together.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download